Remains - A Story of the Flying Tigers

HOME > REVIEWS > SAMURAI

Saburo Sakai: Samurai!

First off, let me say that this is one of the grand combat memoirs of World War II--but you knew that, right? If you haven't already done so, go ahead and buy it. It's definitely worth owning.

Now let me mention some of its flaws. They begin with the true author, who was not Saburo Sakai but the late sci-fi and aviation writer Martin Caidin. It's a shame that this unique story fell into Caidin's dream factory, in which speed generally trumped accuracy. (By some accounts, he wrote 150 books.) In his foreword, for example, Caidin pounces on the fact that the American pilot Colin Kelly didn't sink the battleship Haruna, as we were told at the time--while propagating the myth that it was Sakai who shot down Kelly's bomber. Nor does he question Sakai's 64 "confirmed" victories, when a bit of messing about in the records shows that the Japanese routinely claimed five or ten victories for each Allied plane shot down.

Here are three instances of Caidin's myth-making:

Poland's Daughter

Such easily provable errors ought to have been footnoted in what purports to be a new edition, and the publisher should also have noted some of the other small inaccuracies that pepper the manuscript. Saburo Sakai is not just another pilot, after all--he's an icon of World War II.

I found it amusing to read of Sakai's frustration when (as Caidin states on his behalf) the Zeros succeeded in shooting down American aircraft by the tens and twenties, only to have them miraculously appear again next day: "The Allies seemed to have an inexhaustible supply of aircraft. A week never went by without the enemy suffering losses, yet his planes came, by two and threes and by the dozens." The AVG Flying Tigers in Burma were similarly mystified by the ability of the Japanese squadrons to regenerate themselves. Somehow it never occurred to either side to question their own combat claims.

Sakai phone card Of great interest is Sakai's description of his training. First, the brutality of it, which goes far to explain why Japanese military men were so bestial to their captives. Then there was the wrong-headed emphasis on selectivity. The math was extraordinary: 1,500 seamen applied for a place in the 1937 Non-Commissioned Officer Class with Sakai; 70 were admitted; and 25 graduated to become pilots in the Japanese Navy Air Force. Of this number, only 10 were fighter pilots, who were joined by 6 navy officers and 10 aviation cadets graduating that year. So in the year that Japan went to war against China and eventually much of the Western world, it added a grand total of 26 fighter pilots to its navy, whose air force was larger and more important than the army's. (Sakai is shown at left as a young pilot in China. He was the only member of his class to survive the war.) How vastly different, and in the end more successful, was the American policy of training huge numbers of pilots, and taking them out of combat after roughly a year, so they could pass on their skills to the next generation of fighter pilots.

Finally, I must confess to a bit of irritation when I read of Sakai's merry massacres of "the enemy." Those air crews he supposedly shot down were, after all, my countrymen. Not only that, but they were fighting against the aggressor, and a particularly cruel one at that. Sakai, by contrast, was flying and fighting on behalf of the evil unleashed by Japanese militarism in the 1930s. He may have been a great pilot and a masterful shooter, but his cause was vile.


Also on this website: an interview with Saburo Sakai and Rethinking the Sakai myths.

Question? Comment? Newsletter? Send me an email. Blue skies! -- Dan Ford

Flying Tigers

On this website: Front page | Flying Tigers | Chinese Air Force | Japan at War | Brewster Buffalo | Glen Edwards & the Flying Wing | Vietnam | War in the Modern World | Bluie West One | Poland 1939-1948 | Book Club | Book reviews | Question? | Google us | Website & webmaster | Site map

Other sites: Flying Tigers: the book | Daniel Ford's blog | Daniel Ford's books | Facebook | Piper Cub Forum | Raintree County | Reading Proust | Expedition Yacht Seal

Posted June 2019. Websites © 1997-2019 Daniel Ford; all rights reserved.